Rabbi Wallerstein tells the story of a young boy in 8th grade who he calls Chaim. Chaim came from a non religious home but went to a religious school. In 8th grade he became very close to his rebbe and began growing in yiddishkeit. His first Rosh Hashana experience was at his rebbe’s home and he loved it. But at the end of 8th grade, despite his rebbe’s pleading him to go on to a religious high school, his parents had had enough of paying for Jewish school and decided to send him to public school. His rebbe told them he could get Chaim in for free but his parents wouldn’t let him.
Chaim was also a very gifted basketball player. Already in middle school he stood out- and now in public high school he was at the top of his game. All of the colleges heard that there was this really great ball player in Brooklyn. It was now his senior year in high school and all the scouts from all the schools with the major basketball teams had heard of him and he’s already thinking about skipping college and going straight to the NBA.
This whole time he was still in touch with his 8th grade rebbe. He wasn’t religious but he would still go every year on Rosh Hashana to his rebbe’s home. His senior year he called his rebbe to apologize and to explain that he wouldn’t be able to make it this year for Rosh Hashana- the championship game was that day and all the college scouts and the NBA scouts were going to be at that game. His rebbe begged him to at least please come to hear shofar being blown at 1pm before his 3pm game but Chaim said he couldn’t and tried to explain to his rebbe about warming up and talking to the press and the scouts. His rebbe begged him- theres a break b/w shachris and mussaf and I just want to bentch you- please come. Chaim agreed and on RH he biked up to his rebbe’s home wearing his gym clothes and sneakers.
The Rebbe notices Chaim’s nervousness and asked him if he was ok. Chaim tried to explain- Rebbbe you don’t understand- this is it- this is everything- I have to be the best today- theyre all gonna be there and I’m not gonna forget you- I’m gonna make you so proud of me and I’m gonna get you tickets when im playing in Madison Square Garden. This is the most important day of my life so far- they’re all gonna be judging me. I haven’t slept in days- all I’ve been doing is practicing!
The rebbe says offers to get Chaim a drink and says when he comes back with it he’ll give him a bracha. He goes into the kitchen- Chaim is waiting and waiting and finally the rebbe comes back and gives Chaim the bracha- “you should be g’bentched. Hashem should give you a good year”. Chaim says thanks and tells the rebbe he’ll see him in a few years in the Garden. The rebbe sadly said goodbye.
Chaim left on his bike and all of a sudden BOOM! He goes flying off his bike- hits the ground- he starts telling himself- im ok nothing happened- ill be ok I have to go to the game… and starts thinking that it must have been that someone from the opposition team hit him so he wouldn’t be able to play. All of a sudden the woman from the car jumps out and is over him and shes screaming “oh my G-d.. I never saw so much blood. I’ve never seen anything like this before” and she faints… Everyone is getting out of their cars “oh my G-d. He’s not gonna make it” and Chaim is thinking- “what do you mean I wont make it I have a few hours till the game I just have to get up and go” An ambulance comes flying in and he hears ones of the medics saying “this is a waste of time but this is what we get paid for so ok”. They get Chaim on a stretcher and he’s screaming “get me off this stretcher I have to go play my game. I’m the man! Im gonna be a knick one day I have to get out of here!!” theyre ignoring him and he’s screaming “how much did they pay you? How much did they have to pay to get the truck and make it look like an ambulance?” They get him to the hospital and rush him into surgery and Chaim is still screaming “why are you ignoring me?? This is crazy! What is this? The other team hired all of you just so I wouldn’t play?!?! This is crazy!!! Let me out of here!! I must be really good if they hired a whole hospital staff just so I wouldn’t play” and then he heard a nurse say “I’m sorry. It’s over”
They cover him up- little chaim at the top of his game ready to be a pro and hes covered by a white sheet. A few minutes later in walks his parents- “finally” he thinks “the other team definitely couldn’t pay off my parents- they’ll get me out of here” He hears his parents screaming “my Kenny” (his English name) “oh my G-d I cant believe it. My Kenny” His parents are sobbing “he’s so young” and Chaim can’t believe it “mom what are you doing- they didn’t pay you too” He begins to suspect that something is really wrong. They wheel him downstairs and put him in a fridge. He begins screaming at the top of his lungs and gets no reaction. “This is crazy! I put up with the ambulance and the hospital and even my parents went along but it’s cold in here so get me out!!!”
All of a sudden theres a bright light and he’s no longer in the fridge. He’s standing in a room and he sees theres a table with 3 people sitting there with talleisim over their heads. All of a sudden a huge angel comes walking out and says “Chaim do you know where you are?” “No” “Chaim, you’re in shamayim” “What am I doing in shamayaim!!” “What are you talking about? It’s Rosh Hashana and you were hit by a car and killed” “but I’m so young. How could this happen” And the malach says “don’t worry. I’m the malach Michael. I’m going to take care of you. I’m your defense attorney. Don’t worry.” So Chaim asks “what happens now?” And Michael explains that they’re going to judge you and if the good side wins you go to Gan Eden and if the bad side wins you go to Gehenom” Chaim starts screaming “whats gan eden? Whats gehenom?”
At that moment the most disgusting, meanest thing that you can ever imagine comes walking out. “Hey whats up Chaim. Recognize me? I’m the yetzer hara! I’m the satan! How you doing?” “I don’t know you” “ohhh you know me very well”
Theres a knock at the table and one of the men scream out “Judgment” A huge scare is wheeled out- the kids with 2 sides and Michael explains to Chaim “they take all of your good deeds and put them on one side and all of your bad deeds and put them on the other side. If the good side ways more you go to Gan Eden and if the bad side wins you go to Gehenom. But don’t worry Chaim. You’re a good boy!” The satan walks over to him and starts laughing “you’re mine! I’ve owned you since you were a little kid. Come, let me show you where you’re going!” The yetzer hara opens a window and shows Chaim people writhing in pain- undergoing the most intense torture. And they’re all screaming “one more chance! Give me one more chance on Earth and I’ll do better!! Send me back to the world and I’ll do teshuva” Chaim sees this and starts screaming that he doesn’t want to go there and starts screaming “Hashem please I don’t want to go there please help me!!” And the satan laughs “everyone starts talking to Hashem when they get here! You should’ve spoken to Hashem when you were down there”
Michael then takes Chaim to a different window. He shows him all of the tzadikim sitting and learning. They aren’t worried about the stock market, the latest tv shows, or even the NBA- it’s just them, a gemara and G-d. They were free from blackberries, ipods- everything- they were unplugged- out of the world- just the tzaddikim and G-d. He saw how happy and peaceful they all were and he started begging “Michael please help me!!”
The angel called out ok all the melachim come out and get on the scale. Each angel was according to each mitzvah- so if you put on tefillin but you don’t think about what it is that you’re putting on then you create an angel without a head. The size of the mitzvah is the size and shape of the angel. He had some great big white sumo angels- giants- they get on the scale- all the times he helped his parents, all the times he put on tefillin, all the times in 8th grade that he kept shabbos by his rebbe, all the times he listened to shofar, all the times he kissed the mezuzah! 100s and 1000s of angels in all kinds of sizes got on the scale.
Then it was the satan’s turn. “Is that all you’ve got!! You are beat!! All the aveiros get on the other scale!” And huge gigantic black angels came walking out- mechalel shabbos, non kosher food, clubbing- and the better time you had doing the aveira the bigger the angel- time with girls and loshon hara… and Chaim is crying “nooo I don’t want to go there- I don’t want to get tortured! Noooo” and the satan is jeering at him “Nu? Who’s winning now!?!? You’re mine little boy! You’re mine!” and Chaim is crying “Michael help me!!” the satan turns to the rabbis- “look rabbis I have him beat 100 to 1 he goes to gehenom now!” Michael stops him though- “wait! It says that a person who has the right kevana- who wants to do a mitzvah but for whatever reason he cant it’s as if he did the mitzvah. Chaim’s parents weren’t frum but he wanted to do good” Michael called down the hall “all the melachim that are Chaim’s good thoughts come on down” Huge white angels come out and get on the scale. In the end it’s exactly even.
The satan turns to the rabbis” so nu? It’s even- 6 months in heaven and 6 months with me in hell” The rabbis are thinking- this doesn’t happen very often- they turn to each of them- do you have anything else to add- but neither of them do. All of a sudden there’s a scream in the beis din- “wait one minute! There’s an angel coming down the hall!” Everyone is straining to see what color the angel is- is it black or white!! This is eternity- it’s not like get out of jail in a few years- this is forever! Chaim starts screaming “Michael what is it?? Is it white or black?!?!” and Michael is trying to see but he can’t. And the Satan is laughing “I know what its. It’s a black angel. You’re mine! I’m taking you to the deepest darkest part of Gehenom. It’s over little Chaim”. And Chaim is crying “Hashem please help me” and the satan and the all the black angels are chanting “Black” and Michael and the white angels are chanting “white” and the whole place is in an uproar. And then it walks out- and everyone stops and they look at him- he’s half white and half black!
The satan says “ you know who that is?” and Chaim says “no. I don’t know what that is” and Michael begins muttering “oh no this is not good. We’re in very big trouble” and satan is laughing “I know who it is. He’s mine. You’re done youre finished.” The rabbis on the beis din tell Chaim “go and walk up to angel and ask him who he is” So Chaim goes over to him and explains “look if you’re all white I get to go to gan eden and be happy forever and if you’re all black I belong to that guy and that’s not good so can you please be white for me?” and the angel says “I don’t have that choice. It was your choice. I don’t have that choice.” And Chaim is sobbing “what choice??” and the satan is nudging him on “c’mon angel tell him who you are!!” The angel turns to Chaim and tells him “I am the angel of the blowing of the shofar on Rosh Hashana” and Chaim cant believe “oh my G-d, my rebbe asked me to stay for an extra few minutes. He wanted me to hear shofar. It would have saved me. That one mitzvah could have saved me for eternity. I can’t believe it. It’s a black malach. I got on my bike and I left. I didn’t hear shofar” and the satan begins screaming “you should have listened to your Rebbe. You’re mine! It’s over!” and he digs his claws into chaim’s back and begins pulling him and chaim screams “nooooooooo”
And his Rebbe asks him “Chaim why are you screaming so out of control?” And Chaim can’t believe it “Rebbe! Oh My G-d! Rebbe!!” and the Rebbe starts telling him “I went into the kitchen to get you a drink and you put your head down and I came back in and you were saying things in your sleep and then you started screaming and woke up. You have to get going or you’re going to be late for your game!” Chaim can’t believe it- cant believe that his rebbe would be telling him to go to the basket ball game! “Game? What? I don’t want to go to a game? It’s Rosh Hashana! I have to hear shofar!! Reebbe- why are you telling me to go to a basketball game!?!? I can’t believe you’re my rebbe and you’re telling me to go to the game!” and the rebbe is looking at Chaim like he’s crazy- he’s sitting there with shorts and a jersey and sneakers. He’s ready to play the most important basketball game of his career thus far- with the college and NBA scouts and he only wants to hear shofar?? The Rebbe asks him “I don’t understand whats going on.” So Chaim explains “Rebbe I was on my bike and there was a car and surgery and a cold refrigerator and this big black malach and a big white malach and a little malach that was half white and half black” and his rebbe interrupts him “Chaim- stop smoking that stuff! Especially on Rosh Hashana!” and Chaim just starts crying and tells his rebbe he has to wait for him- that he’ll be back in a half hour- that he needs to change his clothing- and that he cant start the minyan without him.
Rav Wallerstein went to a camp growing up that was very into basketball and used to play the other camps. The camp put a lot of emphasis on winning the basketball games so they used to hire rebbes for seder that knew how to play basketball. Chaim was Rav Wallerstein’s rebbe at camp. Chaim told Rav Wallerstein the story when he was 12 years old. Rav Wallerstein said that he wasn’t so into learning at that point in his life and Chaim told him “Wallerstein, every word could be the word that changes the scale in your favor”
This is exactly what happens to each of us on Rosh Hashana. We each have a scale. On one side they put the white melachim and on the other side the black melachim and whichever side is heavier will determine what your year is going to be like. And it can be one teeny weeny malach that could go on the white side and give you the best year and one teeny weeny black malach that could chas v’shalom give you a terrible year. We all have the choice. We are in this world- we have another chance- they don’t in the next world- but we do! How many white melachim can we gain in the next week and a half until Rosh Hashana so that we get a good judgment?
Rav Wallerstein ended by saying that he has a minhag in his home- with the apple and honey and the fish head- he also has black and white cookies. When his students would ask him why he has the black and white cookies as a siman he would tell this story.
I just want to end by asking Hashem that He should give each of us and all of Klal Yisroel a bracha- that our white angels out number our black angels and that we are each written in the book of life.
Kesiva v’chasima,
Kabat